Stuffed Italian Bread Recipe {with Pizza Toppings} (2024)

This pizza stuffed italian bread recipe is to DIE for! Buttery and crusty, with extra pepperoni and mozzarella, you simply must try it!

Jump to Recipe

This recipe is sponsored by Carbonell and Social Moms.

Stuffed Italian Bread Recipe {with Pizza Toppings} (1)

Stuffed Italian Bread with Pizza

Have you ever eaten Stuffed Italian Bread before? It’s almost a fusion of cheesy garlic bread and pull apart bread. I love how you can add whatever ingredients you’d like to truly make it special for your family.

Stuffed Italian Bread Recipe {with Pizza Toppings} (2)

I decided to turn it into a Pizza-Stuffed Italian Bread for mine, because my kids adore pizza (and I truly love making our own), but because I really wanted this dinner/appetizer to sing using Carbonelli Olive Oil. The result is one of the most glorious, most appetizing dishes you’ve ever seen, it’s almost too pretty to eat.

Stuffed Italian Bread with Pizza Recipe

Using a bread knife (or any serrated knife available), slice gently on the diagonal, in one direction, being careful not to slice all the way to the bottom, then criss-crossing in the opposite direction, creating an X pattern.

Stuffed Italian Bread Recipe {with Pizza Toppings} (3)

Spread out a large piece of tin foil, sprayed with cooking spray, and place the bread on it, ensuring the foil is large enough to fit underneath it and close. (You might need two pieces.) Place the tin foil and bread into the baking pan you will be using.

Stuffed Italian Bread Recipe {with Pizza Toppings} (4)

If you haven’t already, prepare your sausage and cut up your pepperoni; set aside.

Stuffed Italian Bread Recipe {with Pizza Toppings} (5)

Melt the butter, and preheat your oven to 350 degrees. Mix the melted butter, olive oil, seasonings, garlic, and mustard together.

Stuffed Italian Bread Recipe {with Pizza Toppings} (6)

Using a small basting brush, baste the seasoned olive oil mixture into every crevice of the bread, making sure every interior surface has been coated. (It is okay to get it on the crust, too.)

Stuffed Italian Bread Recipe {with Pizza Toppings} (7)

Start stuffing the bread, first with sausage, then with pepperoni.

Stuffed Italian Bread Recipe {with Pizza Toppings} (8)

Finally stuff the bread with both cheeses.

Stuffed Italian Bread Recipe {with Pizza Toppings} (9)

Sprinkle the top with a little more Parmesan.

Stuffed Italian Bread Recipe {with Pizza Toppings} (10)

Spray more cooking spray onto the foil before wrapping the foil closed, so the bread won’t stick, then close the foil, forming a pouch.

Stuffed Italian Bread Recipe {with Pizza Toppings} (11)

Place into the oven for 15-20 minutes; remove the foil from the top and place back into the oven for 5-10 minutes to brown.

Stuffed Italian Bread Recipe {with Pizza Toppings} (12)

Remove from foil and place onto a platter to serve.

Stuffed Italian Bread Recipe {with Pizza Toppings} (13)

You can use a bread knife to cut off sections to serve, or have folks pick up one square at a time if they choose.

Stuffed Italian Bread Recipe {with Pizza Toppings} (14)

The most incredible thing about this Stuffed Italian Bread recipe is that you don’t have to use pizza toppings if you don’t want to (or even the toppings I used), you can stuff it with anything! Cheddar and broccoli stuffed Italian bread? BLT stuffed Italian bread? What about ham and swiss? Or, what about a breakfast stuffed italian bread? OMG! Can you imagine? Yum!!

Stuffed Italian Bread Recipe {with Pizza Toppings} (15)

I promise you, this Stuffed ItalianBread is MAGICAL. It even tastes fantastic as leftovers straight from the fridge the next day without even heating! The cheese, the filling, the herbs, GAH! It’s simply a SHOWSTOPPER, isn’t it? Music for your mouth.

Stuffed Italian Bread Recipe {with Pizza Toppings} (16)

Stuffed Italian Bread Recipe {with Pizza Toppings} (17)

Stuffed Italian Bread with Pizza

Stuffed Italian Bread is almost a fusion of cheesy garlic bread and pull apart bread. I love how you can add whatever ingredients you’d like to truly make it special for your family.

No ratings yet

Print Pin Rate

Ingredients

Instructions

  • Using a bread knife (or any serrated knife available), slice gently on the diagonal, in one direction, being careful not to slice all the way to the bottom, then criss-crossing in the opposite direction, creating an X pattern.

  • Spread out a large piece of tin foil, sprayed with cooking spray, and place the bread on it, ensuring the foil is large enough to fit underneath it and close. (You might need two pieces.) Place the tin foil and bread into the baking pan you will be using.

  • If you haven’t already, prepare your sausage and cut up your pepperoni; set aside.

  • Melt the butter, and preheat your oven to 350 degrees. Mix the melted butter, olive oil, seasonings, garlic, and mustard together.

  • Using a small basting brush, baste the seasoned olive oil mixture into every crevice of the bread, making sure every interior surface has been coated. (It is okay to get it on the crust, too.)

  • Start stuffing the bread, first with sausage, then with pepperoni.

  • Finally stuff the bread with both cheeses.

  • Sprinkle the top with a little more Parmesan.

  • Spray more cooking spray onto the foil before wrapping the foil closed, so the bread won’t stick, then close the foil, forming a pouch.

  • Place into the oven for 15-20 minutes; remove the foil from the top and place back into the oven for 5-10 minutes to brown.

  • Remove from foil and place onto a platter to serve.

  • You can use a bread knife to cut off sections to serve, or have folks pick up one square at a time if they choose.

Tried this recipe?Tag me to show me @crazyadventuresinparenting and/or use #MadeItLikedit to be featured on Pinterest!

For more daringly bold and fun recipes like this one, visitDareToCarbonell.com, where you can experience the three different and bold worlds of Carbonell Olive Oil. You can find more daring blogger-created Carbonell recipes like minehere as well.

Stuffed Italian Bread Recipe {with Pizza Toppings} (18)

What about you? What daring recipe would YOU make using Carbonell olive oil? Do you think this recipe is something your family might enjoy?

Also, be sure to check out my recipe index, which is my virtual recipe box of everything I’ve created. Some more fun pizza themed recipes include my popular Easy Pizza Bread recipe, Pizza Stuffed Burgers, and Pizza Pasta.

Stuffed Italian Bread Recipe {with Pizza Toppings} (19)

Meet Lisa!

Hi, I’m Lisa! Welcome to my perfectly imperfect corner of the web where I've chronicled my life as a mom to "eleventy-billion" kids since 2007! Here I share posts with our family-friendly recipes, crafts and creating art, traveling as a big family, reliving my youth endlessly dancing to 90's music, and documenting our adventurous life while sipping coffee and basking in the delicious Colorado sunshine.

Stuffed Italian Bread Recipe {with Pizza Toppings} (2024)

FAQs

Is pizza dough the same as Italian bread? ›

The main difference is that pizza dough is often made with a higher protein flour (bread flour is perfect). Bread dough can also be made with bread flour (of course) but some types of bread dough are better made with a lower protein flour like all purpose flour.

How to make a loaf of bread from pizza dough? ›

For the bread

Take some leftover pizza dough and on a lightly-floured work surface slice it in half using a dough scraper. Using your fingertips, push downwards on the dough and stretch it out to form two small rolls. Place the rolls onto a lightly-floured pizza peel. Slide the dough off the peel and into your oven.

What is pizza bread called? ›

Focaccia (pronounced fo-kah-cha) is a flat bread similar to pizza dough that can be either sweet or savory.

Can I substitute pizza yeast for bread? ›

Yes. I used pizza yeast to make bread when there were yeast shortages. It was fine. If you've had it for a while, there's a risk that the yeast has died, so I would advise doing the proof step in warm sugar water and make sure it foams.

Can you make bread with store-bought pizza dough? ›

Eventually, she discovered that store-bought pizza dough worked perfectly. A baked loaf creates a bread that's chewy, while also having enough structure and durability to stand strong against fillings and the elements.

What is another name for Italian bread? ›

It takes different names in different parts of Italy. In Rome it is called pane casareccio, which means “homey bread.” In other areas, it is known as pane toscano, “Tuscan bread.” Italians usually get a half loaf or a whole loaf from the bakery.

Can you bake a loaf of bread in a pizza oven? ›

The good news is, it doesn't really matter what kind of pizza oven you have, you can still bake a lovely crusty loaf in it, even if you own a gas oven from a brand other than Igneus.

Can you make bread with 00 pizza flour? ›

Flour: Tipo 00 is a finely ground Italian flour that is considered the gold standard for pizza, pasta, and bread dough.

What can I use instead of pizza dough for bread? ›

Halve a section of baguette or other French bread for an easy alternative crust that needs only to be topped and toasted. Due to its crusty exterior and soft, chewy interior, you'll get the crunch you want with a unique feel and a slightly tangy flavor.

What Italian bread is a cousin of pizza? ›

Focaccia. Focaccia is another Italian bread that has exploded in popularity. It is a relative of pizza, that is oven baked and flat in shape. It is often seasoned with rosemary, sage, and sea salt before baking, and used in sandwiches like the panini.

What does focaccia mean in Italian? ›

The name focaccia derives from the Roman “panis focacius,” meaning “hearth bread”, referring to the fact that focaccia was traditionally baked in coals in Roman times. Its recipe back then consisted of rough flour, olive oil, water, a very small quantity of yeast, and salt, and was probably quite plain.

What's the difference between flatbread and pizza bread? ›

But the difference between the two really comes down to the ingredients, they both need flour, water, and salt, but pizza dough has an additional ingredient, yeast. Pizza dough is a leavened dough where flatbread is unleavened, giving it that flat texture.

Can I use baking soda instead of yeast for bread? ›

You can substitute yeast with equal parts lemon juice and baking soda. So if a recipe calls for 1 teaspoon of yeast, you can use half a teaspoon of lemon juice and half a teaspoon of baking soda. Keep in mind that the bread will not need the typical proofing time and the dough will begin rising right away.

Is dry yeast OK for pizza dough? ›

Dry yeast or powdered yeast, on the other hand, can be preserved much longer and, unlike fresh yeast, must be reactivated in a mixture of warm water and sugar, before being used. Preparing the pizza dough with dry yeast is an excellent alternative if you don't have fresh brewer's yeast in the refrigerator.

Which yeast is best for bread? ›

Active Dry Yeast is an ideal yeast to use for artisan breads or no knead breads that require a slower rise time. It's also the preferred type of yeast for those doughs that proof in the refrigerator for extended periods of time.

What makes Italian pizza dough different? ›

The original Italian pizza is usually thinner and made with mozzarella and tomatoes. People usually eat this dish for dinner. Italians take extra care and time to create their pizza dough. They allow the dough to sit and rise for three days to make it light and fluffy.

What bread is similar to pizza dough? ›

Focaccia bread is a popular Italian flatbread that makes an ideal base for pizza. Thick, hearty focaccia stands up well to heavy toppings and has lots of holes and dimples to trap melted cheese and sauce. Focaccia dough is made from bread flour, olive oil, salt, yeast, and warm water.

What is a substitute for pizza dough? ›

Save time by swapping your regular pizza dough for simple substitutes. Our alternative bases include pitta bread, naan, puff pastry, wraps and polenta. Whether you're short of flour or don't have time to make a pizza base, we've compiled 10 simple shortcuts using shop-bought substitutes.

Are focaccia dough and pizza dough the same? ›

Pizza vs Focaccia

The primary difference is how much yeast is added to the dough and therefore how much the dough is able to rise. Focaccias use more yeast, which gives it a lighter, fluffier texture than a traditional pizza dough and is more closely resembles leavened bread.

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Carlyn Walter

Last Updated:

Views: 6655

Rating: 5 / 5 (50 voted)

Reviews: 89% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Carlyn Walter

Birthday: 1996-01-03

Address: Suite 452 40815 Denyse Extensions, Sengermouth, OR 42374

Phone: +8501809515404

Job: Manufacturing Technician

Hobby: Table tennis, Archery, Vacation, Metal detecting, Yo-yoing, Crocheting, Creative writing

Introduction: My name is Carlyn Walter, I am a lively, glamorous, healthy, clean, powerful, calm, combative person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.